Ask An Economist

Alejandro Badel joined the St. Louis Fed's research staff in 2009 after graduating from Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. His current research is focused on various aspects of household heterogeneity in the U.S. economy. Badel enjoys spending most of his free time with his fiancee and their two pets. For more on his work, see http://research.stlouisfed.org/econ/badel/

Why are U.S. cities so segregated by race?
Why should we care?

Many U.S. cities display a "chocolate city – vanilla suburbs" pattern.1 Although nobody knows for sure why, there are several plausible reasons. As economists, we start with two reasons, concerning preferences and budgets, that may play a role in separating colors in the U.S.

The first force that has been analyzed since the seminal work of Thomas Schelling (winner of the 2005 Nobel Prize in economics) is a preference of each color to be around its own color.2 In particular, Schelling imagined situations in which white households decide where to live using a cutoff rule. If the neighborhood's white population goes below a certain cutoff, they leave. He showed how mixed-race neighborhoods tend to disappear under these conditions, leading to a lot of segregation even when not everybody's cutoff is super high. Why this racial preference exists and how it evolves make up a separate puzzle.

A second force that has been somewhat analyzed is budgetary. For reasons that are unclear and controversial, on average, white households have much higher incomes than black households. This implies that the segregation by race that we observe could be just segregation by income. In other words, there can be segregation by color because only white households can afford the expensive neighborhoods. While this is partly true, some studies have found a significant number of black households that have the means to live in the suburbs yet don't do it. Although I know of no studies that directly report on lower-income white households that struggle too hard to live in the suburbs, this also seems plausible. Therefore, budgets don't seem to tell the full story. A combination of preferences, budgets and other forces seems more plausible.

Why should we care? One important reason to care about segregation by race is related to children. More-expensive neighborhoods usually provide better schools, less noise, less pollution, less crime and better social connections. One may think of these features of neighborhoods as expanding the opportunities parents have to improve the future of their children. Therefore, too much segregation of black households into low-cost neighborhoods could in principle stack the deck against some children.

Endnotes

  1. This playful expression is commonly found in the sociological literature that studies segregation, where it is used non-pejoratively. Apparently, it was first coined in a 1975 album by the funk band Parliament. [back to text]
  2. Schelling, Thomas C. "Models of Segregation." American Economic Review, May 1969, Vol. 59, No. 3, pp. 488-93. [back to text]
Commenting Policy: We encourage comments and discussions on our posts, even those that disagree with conclusions, if they are done in a respectful and courteous manner. All comments posted to our blog go through a moderator, so they won't appear immediately after being submitted. We reserve the right to remove or not publish inappropriate comments. This includes, but is not limited to, comments that are:
  • Vulgar, obscene, profane or otherwise disrespectful or discourteous
  • For commercial use, including spam
  • Threatening, harassing or constituting personal attacks
  • Violating copyright or otherwise infringing on third-party rights
  • Off-topic or significantly political
The St. Louis Fed will only respond to comments if we are clarifying a point. Comments are limited to 1,500 characters, so please edit your thinking before posting. While you will retain all of your ownership rights in any comment you submit, posting comments means you grant the St. Louis Fed the royalty-free right, in perpetuity, to use, reproduce, distribute, alter and/or display them, and the St. Louis Fed will be free to use any ideas, concepts, artwork, inventions, developments, suggestions or techniques embodied in your comments for any purpose whatsoever, with or without attribution, and without compensation to you. You will also waive all moral rights you may have in any comment you submit.
comments powered by Disqus

The St. Louis Fed uses Disqus software for the comment functionality on this blog. You can read the Disqus privacy policy. Disqus uses cookies and third party cookies. To learn more about these cookies and how to disable them, please see this article.