Many times banks will provide their directors with a summary derivation of an appropriate reserve. The reserve adequacy calculation for Insights Bank and Trust (shown here) may be similar to one that you might receive at your bank.


Insights Bank and Trust
Calculation of the Allowance for Loan and Lease Loss
As of September 30, 1994

Loss Estimates
FAS 114 Res. Component $235,518
FAS 5 Reserve Component 76,830
Total $312,348

Acceptable ALLL Range (per ALLL policy)
High +10% $343,582
Low - 10% 281,112

Current ALLL Balance

$283,000
What is the Required Addition to the ALLL?
This is where Mike McCard's recommendation for the $15,000 increase would go.

Normal policy is that the current ALLL balance and the total loss estimates should both be within the acceptable range, as specified in the bank's ALLL policy. There are two questions to ask:

1.) Is the range still appropriate?
2.) If you keep the existing range, is it wise to stay toward the bottom?

The calculation shows estimates of the FAS 114 and 5 components of the reserve, giving an estimated loss in the loan portfolio of $312,347. Per the bank's ALLL policy, the ALLL balance is considered adequate if it falls within 10 percent of the estimated loss. Currently, the Bank's reserve balance stands at $283,000 which is toward the bottom end of the range considered as adequate.

Because the balance falls within the acceptable range, should you move on to the next item? Not necessarily. Click on the question mark button at the bottom of the Insights report on the left.

Here are some questions you should consider:

  • What has been the trend in problem assets?
  • Has the list of problems loans on the "watch list" increased?
  • Have there been any significant changes on the lending staff - older more seasoned lenders being replaced by less experienced lenders? Remember, Mike McCard is new to his job as senior lender.
  • Have there been any changes in the bank's lending philosophy? In this case, the "Visions for Success" program is causing the bank to aggressively seek new lending opportunities.
  • What support is provided to give you faith in the accuracy of the amounts included in the loss estimate calculation? Do you know how they were derived and where they came from?
To make a more informed decision about the ALLL, it would also be helpful to review both the FAS 114 and the FAS 5 information for Insights Bank.

Back to top

Reference View
Print This Page
Meeting Materials
ALLL Policy Guidelines
Asset Quality Assessments
Basic Ratio Analysis
Making Financial Comparisons

Try This At Your Bank
What the Minutes Can Tell You
Determining an Adequate Reserve
Disagreements Among Board Members

 

  Return to Meeting Agenda Page
(Main Page for the Course)
Next >>